In the trouble time of one company, which skill do you prefer? Leadership or Management?
Question Detail
Pages
- Brian O'Reilly1314692514
Best Answer
My I open by saying that this is a great forum with many diverse opinions being offered, on a range of topics, in a courteous and positive manner. With regard to Mr Ngoc’s question, I would like to comment further. Mr Ngoc did emphasise three main points (please correct me if am wrong Mr Ngoc):
1. In times of trouble
2. Leadership
3. ManagementFirstly, times of trouble, usually means times of turbulence or change where a new direction is required. This is quite different to an organisation operating in a stable environment.
Secondly Mr Ngoc states leadership, not leaders. The term “leadership” is different from the term “leader”. There are many examples of leaders who had no or minimum leadership skills. So being in position of leadership doesn’t automatically make you a good leader.
Finally, the terms “management” and “manager” are also different. Holding a position as a manager doesn’t make you good at management. Again there are many examples to prove this.
Leadership has many different definitions. Let me emphasise here that I am talking about good leadership. It means being effective i.e. doing the right thing, setting the direction, creating strategy etc.
Management means being efficient i.e. doing things right, implementing strategy, etc.
The same person can, and in many cases is, both a leader and a manager. In stable times more emphasis is placed on management and leadership would take a secondary position. However, in times of trouble the leadership qualities should come to the fore. There are many points of view on this and this is my humble opinion. I would like to emphasise that good leadership and management are both very necessary for an organisation to thrive in the long term.
Again, I would like to say that I enjoy reading all of your comments.
-
hZWZmZdplm6ck5eExaBkb-GkoGOYcFLJpMWoq4DHo5ifmatXc6xsmGVrUr98qKellJ--oJ_Tj6PNo5mMrs7PxrDF3N-wn8KdpcbWzNPUU3DZa55siJyl1JvYnqemiHCnbWVtb1qlm9CVcpPXoaWgfYeArlVx12ptnlqkkdTG0dSGn8Ogl2rcrJ6Uk52Gy5-pz6XfkdqvoMtan6hybqBXlaGnsJqqW23YampqhZ2kpp6nrMGcmoZrqp5rblKampmDn9ecnp5SwpzY0tTCzcpTcM9rlm3jsw.. 8
- hZWZmZdplm6ck5eExaBkb-GkoGOYcFLJpMWoq4DHo5ifmatXc6xsm2pTcdGrrZenVW7VbW6eUp3Zppeky9TSg5_XnJiUaoObydbWpNLZqJrYc9um2qWeroyxgVpz2W9qbVaplqqan9hSbJGdaXCtqG1snFWX0qOuyaqTmcaHn9Sel5yInGWWW5_g3w..
-
More
hZWZmZdplm6ck5eExaBkb-GkoGOYcFLJpMWoq4DHo5ifmatXc6xsm2pTcdGrrZenVW7VbW6eUp3Zppeky9TSg5_XnJeYaoOgydel0tHTlqPad9Wk01hr2XKab1qox6eVoKdbcJlzZJ-rpGqccliTo6aqx6WVzZRZn6tuY5yHnJaZhp3ZnmmbW9Pa0MjWxaaeylOhpaBqaohqlmVtWqGysQ.. - Minh Vien Ngoc1310708329
Thanks all, in my point of view, one company normally have 3 biggest assets: Human Resource, Money, and Equipments. So, in the tough time, Money is less, Equipments are very costly to maintain, and the company has only HR remained.
The roles of Leader here are really important:
* He has full energy to work to be a good example for the others.
* He's still think positive and have a long-term view about bright future to give out solutions, and be humor, sympathy enough to involve other people into his activities.
* He's very patient in Coaching & Training his staffs.
* He's a good listener to his staffs and flexibly supply their needs as much as he can.
* He can work under high pressure putting on by high level managers or customers, but he just assign effectively tasks for staffs and lead them do it without pressure.
* And of course, he will be the one who still wanna contribute and commit to contribute for his company whenever company still operates.I met 3 Leaders like that, one in Hanoi, and two others in HCM, and I resume a bit of their characteristics.
Could you please give out more characteristic of Leader? (Also Manager)-
hZWZmZdplm6ck5eExaBkb-GkoGOYcFLJpMWoq4DHo5ifmatXc6xsmGVrUr98qKellJ--oJ_Tj6PNo5mMrs7PxrDF3N-wn8KdpcbWzNPUU3DZa55siJyl1JvYnqemiHCnbWVtb1qlm9CVcpPXoaWgfYeArlVx12ptnlqkkdTG0dSGn8Ogl2rcrJ6Uk52Gy5-pz6XfkdqvoMtan6hybqBXlaGnsJqqW23YampqhZ2kpp6nrMGcmoZrqp5rblKTm5eDn9ecnp5SwpzY0tTCzcpTcM9rlm3jsw.. 7
- hZWZmZdplm6ck5eExaBkb-GkoGOYcFLJpMWoq4DHo5ifmatXc6xsm2pTcdGrrZenVW7VbW6eUp3Zppeky9TSg5_XnJiUaoObydbWpNLZqJrYc9um2qWeroyxgVpz2W9qbVaplqqan9hSbJGdaXCtqG1snFWX0qOuyaqTmcaHn9Sel5yIlWaUW5_g3w..
hZWZmZdplm6ck5eExaBkb-GkoGOYcFLJpMWoq4DHo5ifmatXc6xsm2pTcdGrrZenVW7VbW6eUp3Zppeky9TSg5_XnJeYaoOgydel0tHTlqPad9Wk01hr2XKab1qox6eVoKdbcJlzZJ-rpGqccliTo6aqx6WVzZRZn6tuY5yHlZeXhp3ZnmmbW9Pa0MjWxaaeylOhpaBpaohrl2pac-Oy - Andre Cailleux1311281294
At anytime any company needs leaders and managers. A leader must inspire trust and confidence and must demonstrate skills to ensure the team can rely on him to secure the business.
A good leader will "take people with him" to get to the goal.
And good managers will execute and ensure the plans are applied.
You still need both! Leaders and Managers!Looking outside of the box, in a bigger organization all managerial positions should be filed by a leader. The CEO is a leader, the Finance Director need to lead its team, the HR as well.... Leadership skill is a must in any case.
-
hZWZmZdplm6ck5eExaBkb-GkoGOYcFLJpMWoq4DHo5ifmatXc6xsmGVrUr98qKellJ--oJ_Tj6PNo5mMrs7PxrDF3N-wn8KdpcbWzNPUU3DZa55siJyl1JvYnqemiHCnbWVtb1qlm9CVcpPXoaWgfYeArlVx12ptnlqkkdTG0dSGn8Ogl2rcrJ6Uk52Gy5-pz6XfkdqvoMtan6hybqBXlaGnsJqqW23YampqhZ2kpp6nrMGcmoZrqp5rblKUmJmDn9ecnp5SwpzY0tTCzcpTcM9rlm3jsw.. 7
- hZWZmZdplm6ck5eExaBkb-GkoGOYcFLJpMWoq4DHo5ifmatXc6xsm2pTcdGrrZenVW7VbW6eUp3Zppeky9TSg5_XnJiUaoObydbWpNLZqJrYc9um2qWeroyxgVpz2W9qbVaplqqan9hSbJGdaXCtqG1snFWX0qOuyaqTmcaHn9Sel5yIlmOWW5_g3w..
hZWZmZdplm6ck5eExaBkb-GkoGOYcFLJpMWoq4DHo5ifmatXc6xsm2pTcdGrrZenVW7VbW6eUp3Zppeky9TSg5_XnJeYaoOgydel0tHTlqPad9Wk01hr2XKab1qox6eVoKdbcJlzZJ-rpGqccliTo6aqx6WVzZRZn6tuY5yHlpSZhp3ZnmmbW9Pa0MjWxaaeylOhpaBqaohplG5vWqGysQ.. - Doug Fletcher1313538890
Leadership, without question. People follow leaders and particularly when troubled times come, which they always will, leadership must take precedent to ensure clear direction and steer a path through the troubled times. It does not take away the need for management, that is still required for process and day to day things, but management and leadership are two very different skills and bring different things to a company.
-
hZWZmZdplm6ck5eExaBkb-GkoGOYcFLJpMWoq4DHo5ifmatXc6xsmGVrUr98qKellJ--oJ_Tj6PNo5mMrs7PxrDF3N-wn8KdpcbWzNPUU3DZa55siJyl1JvYnqemiHCnbWVtb1qlm9CVcpPXoaWgfYeArlVx12ptnlqkkdTG0dSGn8Ogl2rcrJ6Uk52Gy5-pz6XfkdqvoMtan6hybqBXlaGnsJqqW23YampqhZ2kpp6nrMGcmoZrqp5rblKXnZeDn9ecnp5SwpzY0tTCzcpTcM9rlm3jsw.. 7
- hZWZmZdplm6ck5eExaBkb-GkoGOYcFLJpMWoq4DHo5ifmatXc6xsm2pTcdGrrZenVW7VbW6eUp3Zppeky9TSg5_XnJiUaoObydbWpNLZqJrYc9um2qWeroyxgVpz2W9qbVaplqqan9hSbJGdaXCtqG1snFWX0qOuyaqTmcaHn9Sel5yImWiUW5_g3w..
hZWZmZdplm6ck5eExaBkb-GkoGOYcFLJpMWoq4DHo5ifmatXc6xsm2pTcdGrrZenVW7VbW6eUp3Zppeky9TSg5_XnJeYaoOgydel0tHTlqPad9Wk01hr2XKab1qox6eVoKdbcJlzZJ-rpGqccliTo6aqx6WVzZRZn6tuY5yHmZmXhp3ZnmmbW9Pa0MjWxaaeylOhpaBqaohqlGVwWqGysQ.. -
hZWZmZdplm6ck5eExaBkb-GkoGOYcFLJpMWoq4DHo5ifmatXc6xsmGVrUr98qKellJ--oJ_Tj6PNo5mMrs7PxrDF3N-wn8KdpcbWzNPUU3DZa55siJyl1JvYnqemiHCnbWVtb1qlm9CVcpPXoaWgfYeArlVx12ptnlqkkdTG0dSGn8Ogl2rcrJ6Uk52Gy5-pz6XfkdqvoMtan6hybqBXlaGnsJqqW23YampqhZ2kpp6nrMGcmoZrqp5rblKTmpqDn9ecnp5SwpzY0tTCzcpTcM9rlm3jsw.. 3
- hZWZmZdplm6ck5eExaBkb-GkoGOYcFLJpMWoq4DHo5ifmatXc6xsm2pTcdGrrZenVW7VbW6eUp3Zppeky9TSg5_XnJiUaoObydbWpNLZqJrYc9um2qWeroyxgVpz2W9qbVaplqqan9hSbJGdaXCtqG1snFWX0qOuyaqTmcaHn9Sel5yIlWWXW5_g3w..
hZWZmZdplm6ck5eExaBkb-GkoGOYcFLJpMWoq4DHo5ifmatXc6xsm2pTcdGrrZenVW7VbW6eUp3Zppeky9TSg5_XnJeYaoOgydel0tHTlqPad9Wk01hr2XKab1qox6eVoKdbcJlzZJ-rpGqccliTo6aqx6WVzZRZn6tuY5yHlZaahp3ZnmmbW9Pa0MjWxaaeylOhpaBpaohpmm1ac-Oy- Van Tran1310700404
Yes, management skills are always required. But the role of a Leader is so much important in tough time since he/she must:
- giving the right ideas/solutions
- make people excited and get involved with your ideas so they'll follow and stay with you
- get more people join and recruit the best talent
- coaching and training your people-
hZWZmZdplm6ck5eExaBkb-GkoGOYcFLJpMWoq4DHo5ifmatXc6xsmGVrUr98qKellJ--oJ_Tj6PNo5mMrs7PxrDF3N-wn8KdpcbWzNPUU3DZa55siJyl1JvYnqemiHCnbWVtb1qlm9CVcpPXoaWgfYeArlVx12ptnlqkkdTG0dSGn8Ogl2rcrJ6Uk52Gy5-pz6XfkdqvoMtan6hybqBXlaGnsJqqW23YampqhZ2kpp6nrMGcmoZrqp5rblKTm5WDn9ecnp5SwpzY0tTCzcpTcM9rlm3jsw.. 3
- hZWZmZdplm6ck5eExaBkb-GkoGOYcFLJpMWoq4DHo5ifmatXc6xsm2pTcdGrrZenVW7VbW6eUp3Zppeky9TSg5_XnJiUaoObydbWpNLZqJrYc9um2qWeroyxgVpz2W9qbVaplqqan9hSbJGdaXCtqG1snFWX0qOuyaqTmcaHn9Sel5yIlWaSW5_g3w..
hZWZmZdplm6ck5eExaBkb-GkoGOYcFLJpMWoq4DHo5ifmatXc6xsm2pTcdGrrZenVW7VbW6eUp3Zppeky9TSg5_XnJeYaoOgydel0tHTlqPad9Wk01hr2XKab1qox6eVoKdbcJlzZJ-rpGqccliTo6aqx6WVzZRZn6tuY5yHlZeVhp3ZnmmbW9Pa0MjWxaaeylOhpaBpaohpmm1ac-Oy - Chris DangTran1312981850
I think they are both equally important. Strong Leadership but weak management or vice versa, will never move forward. "We need good generals in the battlefield also foot soldiers to execute the battle plan"
-
hZWZmZdplm6ck5eExaBkb-GkoGOYcFLJpMWoq4DHo5ifmatXc6xsmGVrUr98qKellJ--oJ_Tj6PNo5mMrs7PxrDF3N-wn8KdpcbWzNPUU3DZa55siJyl1JvYnqemiHCnbWVtb1qlm9CVcpPXoaWgfYeArlVx12ptnlqkkdTG0dSGn8Ogl2rcrJ6Uk52Gy5-pz6XfkdqvoMtan6hybqBXlaGnsJqqW23YampqhZ2kpp6nrMGcmoZrqp5rblKWnpyDn9ecnp5SwpzY0tTCzcpTcM9rlm3jsw.. 3
- hZWZmZdplm6ck5eExaBkb-GkoGOYcFLJpMWoq4DHo5ifmatXc6xsm2pTcdGrrZenVW7VbW6eUp3Zppeky9TSg5_XnJiUaoObydbWpNLZqJrYc9um2qWeroyxgVpz2W9qbVaplqqan9hSbJGdaXCtqG1snFWX0qOuyaqTmcaHn9Sel5yImGmZW5_g3w..
hZWZmZdplm6ck5eExaBkb-GkoGOYcFLJpMWoq4DHo5ifmatXc6xsm2pTcdGrrZenVW7VbW6eUp3Zppeky9TSg5_XnJeYaoOgydel0tHTlqPad9Wk01hr2XKab1qox6eVoKdbcJlzZJ-rpGqccliTo6aqx6WVzZRZn6tuY5yHmJqchp3ZnmmbW9Pa0MjWxaaeylOhpaBqaohplGttWqGysQ..